When Love Hurts: Mental health impact of romantic breakups
As young adults grapple with life’s pivotal decisions what to study, what career path to pursue, and whom to spend their lives with they often face a critical period of identity development. Emerging adulthood, spanning ages 18 to 25, is a time marked by exploration and frequent change, with the brain still developing in areas crucial for higher cognitive and emotional functions.
This stage, caught between adolescence and full adulthood, is particularly vulnerable to the impacts of significant life events, including romantic breakups.
Rethinking the Psychological Impact
Recent research highlights a growing concern: romantic breakups can have a profound psychological impact, potentially equating to trauma. Although traditionally dismissed as a mere rite of passage, emerging evidence suggests that these breakups can lead to severe emotional distress, including intrusive thoughts, intense grief, and even suicidal tendencies. Despite this, psychiatric literature has largely overlooked breakups as potential traumatic events.
Validating Breakups as Traumatic Events
A recent study by mental health researcher Alberta SJ van der Watt, alongside colleagues, sought to address this gap by examining whether breakups could be classified as potentially traumatic according to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5). This manual, used by mental health professionals to diagnose conditions like post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), includes specific criteria for what constitutes a traumatic event. The research focused on whether breakups meet Criterion A of the DSM-5, which involves exposure to actual or threatened death, serious injury, or sexual violence.
Breakup Trauma vs. Traditional Traumatic Events
The study involved university students who were divided into three groups based on their experiences: those who reported post-traumatic stress symptoms from breakups, those who had experienced other DSM-5-defined traumatic events (such as assault), and a control group with non-traumatic stress experiences. Participants from the breakup group exhibited significantly higher levels of symptoms like flashbacks and nightmares related to their former partners compared to the other groups.
How Breakups Affect Emotional Processing
Brain scans conducted as part of the study revealed that the breakup group showed similar activation patterns in the amygdala and hippocampus—regions associated with PTSD—when viewing images of their ex-partners, akin to the response observed in those who had experienced physical or sexual assault.
READ ALSO: Pete Edochie reveals reason why Nigerian women get beaten in marriage
Who Feels the Breakup Trauma Most?
Further analysis identified that factors such as sex, sexual orientation, and religion influenced the severity of distress experienced from breakups. Notably, those with minority sexual orientations or who identified as non-religious reported heightened breakup-related distress.
Enhancing Support for Breakup Trauma
The findings suggest that recognising breakups as potentially traumatic could lead to more effective mental health support for young adults. Mental health services and university counselling centres should consider screening for PTSD symptoms in students experiencing breakups and provide appropriate trauma-focused treatments, such as prolonged exposure therapy.
Expanding the Understanding of Breakup Trauma
While these findings challenge traditional views and indicate that not all breakups are necessarily traumatic, they underscore the need for more comprehensive research with diverse populations to fully understand the psychological impacts of romantic relationships.
Acknowledging and addressing the profound emotional effects of romantic breakups can provide much-needed support for young adults navigating this tumultuous period in their lives. By validating their experiences and offering targeted interventions, we can better assist them in managing and overcoming these challenges.
